Episode 198: Actually, Substack Doesn't Have a Nazi Problem

Blocked and Reported

410

1×

0:00

-1:01:21

Episode 198: Actually, Substack Doesn't Have a Nazi Problem

How bad reporting created a panic over nothing

Jan 13, 2024

∙ Paid

410

This week on Blocked and Reported, Jesse and Katie dig into allegations that Substack is sheltering Nazis like so many Jews in an attic. Plus, world’s best/worst Wife Guy Bill Ackman continues to post.

To support the show: become a Primo subscriber and get three extra episodes a month and more.

Singal-Minded

Platformer’s Reporting On Substack’s Supposed “Nazi Problem” Is Shoddy And Misleading

As some of you know, there’s presently a debate raging about the fact that Substack will not automatically ban Nazis who pop up on this platform. That’s because Substack’s content guidelines are written in an intentionally liberal way, to allow most speech. One of the only red lines is direct, credible incitement of violence — racism alone, including of…

4 months ago · 527 likes · 118 comments · Jesse Singal

Singal-Minded

There Are Major Factual Issues With Jonathan M. Katz’s ‘Atlantic’ Article, “Substack Has A Nazi Problem”

Some quick housekeeping things: —This newsletter has been trending toward loooooong posts lately. I’m aware of that and will try to mix things up a bit more over the next couple months. —Immediately contradicting what I just said, Part 2 of my exploration of the…

4 months ago · 94 likes · 30 comments · Jesse Singal

Premium: The Huffington Post Roasts Hoste

August 16, 2023

This week on the Primo episode of Blocked and Reported, Jesse and Katie discuss a recent article on the poster/writer Richard Hanania, aka Richard Hoste, and his racist past (and…

Read full story

Jonathan Katz: “Substack Has a Nazi Problem”

https://substack.com/content

Patrick Casey archive

Platformer

Why Substack is at a crossroads

Most days, this column looks at controversies unfolding on other tech platforms. Today, let’s take a look at the one that hosts this publication: Substack. On Tuesday, I told subscribers that we are considering leaving the platform based on the company’s recent statement that it would not demonetize or remove openly Nazi …

4 months ago · 689 likes · 27 comments · Casey Newton

Platformer

Substack says it will remove Nazi publications from the platform

Substack is removing some publications that express support for Nazis, the company said today. The company said this did not represent a reversal of its previous stance, but rather the result of reconsidering how it interprets its existing policies…

4 months ago · 856 likes · 45 comments · Casey Newton

Platformer

Why Platformer is leaving Substack

After much consideration, we have decided to move Platformer off of Substack. Over the next few days, the publication will migrate to a new website powered by the nonprofit, open-source publishing platform Ghost. If you already subscribe to Platformer…

4 months ago · 514 likes · 34 comments · Casey Newton

Public

Censors Are Trying to Trick You Into Thinking Substack Has a "Nazi Problem"

America’s censors have worked their way through complaining about virtually every last pocket of free speech left and are now returning to an old foe: Substack, the newsletter platform this publication is published on. The latest complaint began with a piece in The Atlantic by the journalist Jonathan Katz…

4 months ago · 978 likes · 139 comments · Zaid Jilani and Alex Gutentag

Substackers Against Nazis open letter

Substack Shouldn’t Decide What We Read open letter

Listen to this episode with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Blocked and Reported to listen to this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Blocked and Reported

Journalists Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal scour the internet for its craziest, silliest, most sociopathic content, part of an obsessive and ill-conceived attempt to extract kernels of meaning and humanity from a landscape of endless raging dumpster fires.

Listen on