Whatever they identify as, this trans woman is not referring to them as any sort of woman.
`I thought it...'
Yes, there is a disagreement about what it means to be trans within the LGBTQ community. Being trans is a medical issue and, to my mind, demands and accommodations should only be made on society, for this issue, based on that fact.
Yes, Brianna Wu has made a similar point. Yes, these disagreements (over whether or not trans is a medical condition) are making a mess of what used to be a consensus.
But that goes back to my point: this guy Josh wasn't doing things so differently from certain members of the LGBTQ community: mixing up the signifiers, declaring it doesn't have to be a medical condition, etc. And so it's difficult to assess: is he LARPing? is he sincere? is he mentally unstable? Does it matter? Maybe not.
`wasn't doing things so differently from certain members of the LGBTQ community: mixing up the signifiers, declaring it doesn't have to be a medical condition, etc.'
A significant portion of the trans community has little, and increasingly less, tolerance for this type of stuff. Things have gotten to the point, politically, where it's no longer just irritating* but will cause harm to actual trans people---like having our medical care taken away---and I imagine we will be much more definitive on what and who needs to be protected.
*I'm an Xennial professor and don't have time or interest in gender fuckery, etc. There are more important and rewarding things in my life than playing with gender.
Jeffrey Marsh? What is s/he doing w/ facial hair? I thought it had become a thing among some in the trans community to mix up the signifiers of sex?
Whatever they identify as, this trans woman is not referring to them as any sort of woman.
`I thought it...'
Yes, there is a disagreement about what it means to be trans within the LGBTQ community. Being trans is a medical issue and, to my mind, demands and accommodations should only be made on society, for this issue, based on that fact.
Yes, Brianna Wu has made a similar point. Yes, these disagreements (over whether or not trans is a medical condition) are making a mess of what used to be a consensus.
But that goes back to my point: this guy Josh wasn't doing things so differently from certain members of the LGBTQ community: mixing up the signifiers, declaring it doesn't have to be a medical condition, etc. And so it's difficult to assess: is he LARPing? is he sincere? is he mentally unstable? Does it matter? Maybe not.
`wasn't doing things so differently from certain members of the LGBTQ community: mixing up the signifiers, declaring it doesn't have to be a medical condition, etc.'
A significant portion of the trans community has little, and increasingly less, tolerance for this type of stuff. Things have gotten to the point, politically, where it's no longer just irritating* but will cause harm to actual trans people---like having our medical care taken away---and I imagine we will be much more definitive on what and who needs to be protected.
*I'm an Xennial professor and don't have time or interest in gender fuckery, etc. There are more important and rewarding things in my life than playing with gender.